The delicious Tuscan “mush” of stale bread soaked into luscious tomato-ish soup, served with a splash of evoo and leaves of aromatic sweet basil. Of course, in the summer–and I’m writing this at the beginning of August–pappa al pomodoro is all about sweet ripe fresh from the vine summer tomatoes; but in the winter, pappa is also delicious eating with canned tomatoes–I once went on a vineyard visiting tour which ended up feeling more like a pappa al pomodoro tour, as each of my hosts brought out a bowlful of the thick uber-savoury mixture, saying: this wine, its perfect with pappa al pomodoro! I remember one host saying: “yes, even in the winter I love it: use good quality Italian canned tomatoes!”.
If you’ve ever spooned up pappa al pomodoro, you know it is soooooo soothing, comforting, and ever-so-filling. My friend Judy, in Tuscany, likes it so thick “I can eat it with a knife and fork”. For that, though, you need really fabulous bread: bread with substance and flavour that doesn’t turn gummy. The best bread to use is bread that is very very dry; Judy uses unseasoned croutons, I simply save bread as it stales and let it go very hard. What I don’t use for the pappa will another time become bread pudding.
In keeping with the spirit of this dish, my measurements are not so exact that you need adhere to them. For one thing, your bread will have different thickening qualities as it will be a different bread and a different degree of dryness. Ditto for your tomatoes; in fact, I recommend that you use half fresh and half canned tomatoes for this as the canned tomatoes have a more intense flavour from the cooking involved in canning. I don’t mind tomato skins, however; if you do, you’ll need to skin the tomatoes before using them.
And though tomatoes are already little umami-bursts, I’m letting you into a little secret: I like to add a mysterious umami-boost in the form of a porcini bouillion/stock cube, in fact, for 6 cups/1 litre of water, I use two cubes. You can’t really taste it, but the pappa tastes elusively and indefinably more savoury. Chicken or vegetable broth, or plain water, are equally though slightly differently, delicious. If you can’t find porcini boullion cubes, take a few dried porcini mushroom slices and crush in a mortar and pestle, or just break up, and add to the simmering soup. If its crushed you don’t know its there, if its in small pieces, okay, you know its there, but is that a bad thing? when its porcini, i think its always a good thing. but there IS something to be said for mystery.
6-8 cloves garlic; lightly crushed (I leave the skins on as they fall apart during cooking and its so much easier)
About 1/4 cup evoo
3-4 cups ripe tomatoes, coarsely chopped
1 can/tin (about 350g/14 oz) chopped or plum tomatoes, broken up
6 cups/1 litre broth, water, or combination broth+water
1 loaf country bread (1 lb loaf), cut or broken up, and left to grow stale; if it is not stale enough to the point of dryness, place it in a low oven for half an hour to an hour, then check for dryness). The dryer it is, the more it will absorb the liquid and become thick rather than gummy.
Tiny pinch hot pepper, or add a whole pod of a smallish dried chile at the beginning with the garlic, then fish it out at the end.
In a heavy soup pot heat the olive oil until hot but not smoking, then add the garlic and stir around, letting it just gild and smell gorgeous; you do not want to brown it. I”m talking seconds here.
Add the ripe tomatoes, and cook it together, until it becomes somewhat saucey, say 10 minutes, then add the canned tomatoes, broth and water.
Bring to the boil, cook together about 10 minutes, then add the bread. Cover and remove from the heat; let it sit together as the bread absorbs the liquid, stirring it and breaking it up as it does. In case you have big pieces of bread that refuse to break up, use a big wooden spoon.
Pappa is best at room temperature although you can reheat it and eat it warm. To serve: ladle into bowls and scatter lots of fresh basil over the top, drizzle with evoo, and sprinkle with a little coarse salt if liked/needed.
P.S. I ate the leftover pappa al pomodoro for breakfast and then went to the pool for an hour of garlic-breath powered laps; kinda the best morning ever.
Recent Comments